Situations
Six situations real estate agents run into. Make the calls, get a grade and see what you missed.
They cover open houses, messages and calls, vacant listings, conflict, your personal information and the walk to your car. No answers appear while you play, so go with what you would really do.
Real Safe Agent is now a safety resource instead of a software app, so planning, vetting and practice happen here through guides and graded situations. Browse Resources for checklists and scripts.

Pick a situation
Each one is five quick decisions, about four minutes. Play them in any order.
- 1 · Open houseThe busy open houseEleven visitors, one agent and a man who heads upstairs without signing in.Start this situation
- 2 · Messages and callsThe message that feels wrongA text after you said no, and a voicemail that mentions where you go.Start this situation
- 3 · Vacant listingThe door was already openYou arrive early to a vacant listing and the front door is ajar.Start this situation
- 4 · ConflictThe angry sellerA listing appointment goes sideways and the seller stands between you and the door.Start this situation
- 5 · Personal informationYour personal informationA visitor wants to know where you live, then finds your private account.Start this situation
- 6 · After the showingWalking to your car at duskA last showing ends after dark and someone is waiting near your car.Start this situation
Your report card
Play a situation and your grade shows up here.
What the app used to do, and where it lives now
An earlier version of this site described app tools for agent safety. Those tools are not part of this site now. The needs behind them still matter, so here is where each one is covered today with free guides and practice.
Used to help with: Buddy network and accompaniment
Never go to an appointment or open house alone.
Now: Plan who is with you and who knows where you are.
Used to help with: Check-in alerts
Act when you first feel uncomfortable, not when you are scared.
Now: Practice the calls and the words for ending a visit or holding a boundary.
Situation: The angry sellerGuide: trust your gut, and act on it
Used to help with: Prospect lookups and comfort ratings
Know who you are meeting before you meet them.
Now: Vet the client with ID, a call and a check-in, and spot a message that feels wrong.
Situation: The message that feels wrongGuide: vet the client before you meet
Used to help with: Open house support
The start and the end of an open house are the riskiest moments.
Now: Run the open house with a checklist and a sign-in sheet.
Used to help with: Emergency alerts
Know when and how to get help fast.
Now: Rehearse what to do when something is wrong, including calling 911.
Situation: The door was already openGuide: if something goes wrong
How these are built
The scenarios are invented for practice and are not based on any one person. Each situation is a short run of decisions, and every decision is checked against a named source or marked as our own judgment. Across the six situations that is 30 decisions: 8 rest on named sources alone, 22 pair named sources with a step we mark as our own judgment, and 0 rest on our judgment alone. The tables and charts below are counted from the situations themselves, so they stay current when a situation changes.
How each situation's decisions are backed
Count of decisions per situation, by the kind of evidence behind the strongest move.
- Named sources
- Sources and our judgment
- Our judgment only
| Situation | Named sources | Sources and our judgment | Our judgment only |
|---|---|---|---|
| Open house | 1 | 4 | 0 |
| Message | 1 | 4 | 0 |
| Open door | 0 | 5 | 0 |
| Seller | 2 | 3 | 0 |
| Personal info | 2 | 3 | 0 |
| Car at dusk | 2 | 3 | 0 |
Counted from the situation data. Sources are listed in the Sources section below.
Decisions that cite each source
A decision can cite more than one source, so the bars add up to more than the number of decisions.
| Source | Decisions citing it |
|---|---|
| NAR 56 tips | 20 |
| NAR open house tips | 7 |
| CPI top 10 | 4 |
| SPARC handbook | 4 |
| Arlington PD | 4 |
| Westchester County | 4 |
| SPARC what to do | 3 |
| Brielle PD | 3 |
| Kingsport PD | 2 |
| CPI verbal techniques | 1 |
| DOJ stalking page | 1 |
Source: Counted from the situation data
Every decision and what backs it
Sort by evidence or filter to one situation to see which sources sit behind each decision.
| The busy open house | 1. Before the doors open | Named sources | NAR open house tips |
|---|---|---|---|
| The busy open house | 2. He walks past the sign-in table | Sources and our judgment | NAR open house tips |
| The busy open house | 3. “Are you here by yourself?” | Sources and our judgment | NAR open house tips, NAR 56 tips |
| The busy open house | 4. Five people arrive together | Sources and our judgment | NAR 56 tips, NAR open house tips |
| The busy open house | 5. One visitor stays | Sources and our judgment | NAR open house tips |
| The message that feels wrong | 1. The text | Sources and our judgment | SPARC handbook |
| The message that feels wrong | 2. A voicemail | Sources and our judgment | SPARC what to do, NAR 56 tips |
| The message that feels wrong | 3. He knows about Saturday | Named sources | DOJ stalking page, SPARC what to do, NAR open house tips |
| The message that feels wrong | 4. A call from a blocked number | Sources and our judgment | SPARC handbook, NAR 56 tips |
| The message that feels wrong | 5. The open house goes ahead | Sources and our judgment | NAR open house tips, NAR 56 tips |
| The door was already open | 1. The front door | Sources and our judgment | NAR 56 tips, Arlington PD |
| The door was already open | 2. A light in the window | Sources and our judgment | Arlington PD |
| The door was already open | 3. The client arrives early | Sources and our judgment | Arlington PD, NAR 56 tips |
| The door was already open | 4. The officer arrives | Sources and our judgment | Arlington PD |
| The door was already open | 5. The house is cleared | Sources and our judgment | NAR 56 tips |
| The angry seller | 1. Before you go in | Named sources | NAR 56 tips |
| The angry seller | 2. The number | Named sources | CPI top 10, CPI verbal techniques |
| The angry seller | 3. Between you and the door | Sources and our judgment | CPI top 10, NAR 56 tips |
| The angry seller | 4. He does not move | Sources and our judgment | CPI top 10, NAR 56 tips |
| The angry seller | 5. He calls back | Sources and our judgment | CPI top 10, NAR 56 tips |
| Your personal information | 1. The flyer and the business card | Named sources | NAR 56 tips |
| Your personal information | 2. “Where do you live?” | Named sources | NAR 56 tips |
| Your personal information | 3. A new follower | Sources and our judgment | SPARC handbook, NAR 56 tips |
| Your personal information | 4. He shows up at the office | Sources and our judgment | SPARC handbook, SPARC what to do, NAR 56 tips |
| Your personal information | 5. The sign-in sheets and the ID copy | Sources and our judgment | NAR 56 tips |
| Walking to your car at dusk | 1. Where you park | Named sources | NAR 56 tips |
| Walking to your car at dusk | 2. Someone by your car | Sources and our judgment | NAR 56 tips, Westchester County |
| Walking to your car at dusk | 3. At the car | Sources and our judgment | NAR 56 tips, Westchester County, Brielle PD |
| Walking to your car at dusk | 4. Headlights behind you | Named sources | Kingsport PD, Brielle PD, Westchester County |
| Walking to your car at dusk | 5. At the gas station | Sources and our judgment | Brielle PD, Westchester County, Kingsport PD |
Where no source covers a step, we say so and mark it as our judgment.
Where agents said they feared for their safety (%)
Members who reported such a situation named where it happened. The shares add to more than 100%, so members could name more than one place. Only 6% named a first meeting in a public place.
| Where it happened | % of members |
|---|---|
| Message or call | 29 |
| Showing | 26 |
| Open house | 25 |
| Secluded first meeting | 22 |
| Public first meeting | 6 |
Source: National Association of REALTORS, 2023 Member Safety Residential Report, 2023, p. 6
Survey figures used in the situations
Every number in the situations comes from this one report. Sort by value or by page.
| Feared for their safety or the safety of their information | 22% | p. 5 |
|---|---|---|
| Had not been a victim of a crime while working | 95% | p. 8 |
| Meet new clients at their office or a neutral place (typical respondent) | 65% | p. 4 |
| Met a new client alone at a secluded location in the past 12 months | 35% | p. 10 |
| Showed a vacant property with poor or no phone coverage | 48% | pp. 13 to 14 |
| Felt unsafe while doing so | 34% | pp. 13 to 14 |
| Follow personal safety protocols with every client | 71% | p. 21 |
| Use a smartphone safety app to track their whereabouts | 67% | p. 20 |
NAR surveyed 46,898 residential members and received 1,422 responses (a 3.0% response rate, margin of error 2.6 points at 95% confidence). It is a self-reported survey, not a count of crimes, and it describes agents as a group, not any one showing.
How a decision is scored
You choose one option at each decision.
| Points | What it means |
|---|---|
| 2 | The strongest move for that decision. |
| 1 | Partly right: it covers one habit and leaves a gap |
| 0 | Gives the other person more control than they need |
How points become a grade
Your points as a share of the most you could earn in that situation.
| Grade | Share of points |
|---|---|
| A | 90% or more |
| B | 75% or more |
| C | 60% or more |
| D | 40% or more |
| F | Below 40% |
Scoring is our own design and has not been validated.
A learning exercise. General information, not security advice, and no routine guarantees anyone’s safety.
Sources
Pages were read directly and paraphrased, not quoted. Two of the NAR pages are archived from 2012. Each debrief inside a situation also lists what the sources say for that decision.
Survey figures and warning signs
2023 Member Safety Residential Report
National Association of REALTORS, 2023
Source of every figure in the situations, with the page noted.
The Gift of Fear (pre-incident indicators)
Gavin de Becker, 1997
Source of the named warning signs. Cues not from this book are marked as our judgment.
Guidance behind the recommended moves
National Association of REALTORS® (NAR), 2012
Archived NAR page, dated May 2012.
Cited in 20 decisions: The busy open house, The message that feels wrong, The door was already open, The angry seller, Your personal information, Walking to your car at dusk
10 Tips for Holding a Safe Open House
National Association of REALTORS® (NAR), 2012
Archived NAR page, dated May 2012.
Cited in 7 decisions: The busy open house, The message that feels wrong
CPI’s Top 10 De-escalation Tips Revisited
Crisis Prevention Institute (CPI), 2022
Cited in 4 decisions: The angry seller
SPARC, Stalking Prevention, Awareness, and Resource Center
Cited in 4 decisions: The message that feels wrong, Your personal information
Arlington County (VA) Police Department
Cited in 4 decisions: The door was already open
Westchester County (NY) Department of Public Safety
Cited in 4 decisions: Walking to your car at dusk
What To Do If You Are Being Stalked
SPARC, Stalking Prevention, Awareness, and Resource Center
Cited in 3 decisions: The message that feels wrong, Your personal information
Safety Tips from Your Police Department
Borough of Brielle (NJ) Police Department
Cited in 3 decisions: Walking to your car at dusk
City of Kingsport (TN) Police Department
Cited in 2 decisions: Walking to your car at dusk
5 Verbal De-escalation Techniques
Crisis Prevention Institute (CPI), 2021
Cited in 1 decision: The angry seller
U.S. Department of Justice, Office on Violence Against Women
Cited in 1 decision: The message that feels wrong